Off-topic comments

Excerpt: For the first time in this site's existence, I've had to delete comments for being off-topic. This followed a repeated warning about the off-topic nature of the comments, and a perfectly good opportunity was given for the commenter to change tack and post on-topic instead. The deletion is not due to what was being posted, but rather that it was being posted in the wrong place.

For the first time in this site's existence, I've had to delete comments for being off-topic.

This followed a repeated warning about the off-topic nature of the comments, and a perfectly good opportunity was given for the commenter to change tack and post on-topic instead. The deletion is not due to what was being posted, but rather that it was being posted in the wrong place.

I'm afraid that, due to the nature of blogs, comment threads must be limited to the subject at hand; the discussion is impossible to follow any other way. If, at a future point, there is sufficient call for an open forum then we'll consider setting one up. But for now, as a matter of common courtesy to the people who take the time to write the blog posts, commentators are advised to keep to the matter at hand. Blatantly off-topic posts will not be tolerated; we're liberal, but we're not that liberal!


On 20 June 2006 - 11:22am, Andy (not verified) wrote:

Being liberal is all about letting people do what they want so long as they aren't abusing that right to stop other people doing likewise. Thread-hijack prevents people discussing the original topic and, so long as an opportunity is given for the hijackers to discuss what they want elsewhere, suppressing it is not censorship.

Perhaps you might experiment with an open thread, rather than a whole forum, and see if anyone posts in it? I suspect at this stage it's too early for it to take off, but who knows?


On 20 June 2006 - 9:06pm, MatGB (not verified) wrote:

I second the Open Thread idea; they use them on US blogs a lot, Eurotrib does them, as does Pickled Politics. OK, the latter normally devolves to silly jokes, but they're fun, and as they're on the site, it adds to the sense of coummunity.

I'll likely be using them when I move my site, depends if I finally make a decision about platform...


On 20 June 2006 - 9:46pm, Rob Knight wrote:

*whispers evil thoughts to Mat* use Drupal, use Drupal!